Tatcha Water Cream vs Banish Vitamin C Creme Comparison

tatcha water cream versus banish vitamin c cream
By Brigid Anderson


Finding the right moisturizer for our skin type takes a lot of time and patience and it may feel like a frustrating, never ending chore for someone who wants to achieve  acne-free skin. We would usually research about some creams or skin care products and read reviews then purchase it, assuming that it would work the same for us, only to find out that it doesn’t…

This article features a battle of two face creams: the Tatcha Water Cream and the Banish Vitamin C Creme. Which of the two is better for you? Let's break it down starting with the Tatcha Water Cream.


The Tatcha Water Cream has been dominating the skincare industry world by combining ingredients being used by Japanese Geishas, basing it on the anti-aging superfoods from a Japanese diet and Geisha beauty rituals: green tea, rice and algae. This water cream is an oil-free and anti-aging water cream that releases a burst of skin improving Japanese nutrients, powerful botanicals and optimal hydration for pure and glass-like skin. The Tatcha Water Cream also contains Japanese wild rose, Japanese leopard lily and Hadasei-3™ complex.

The Tatcha Water Cream is reported to be Sephora’s top-selling moisturizer after this product sold out twice in about just a month. Formulated with oily skin in mind, this moisturizer ditches potentially pore-clogging oils for oil-controlling ingredients, like Japanese Leopard Lily.

The Tatcha skin care line was created by Harvard Business School grad Victoria Tsai who suffered from acute dermatitis and eczema until her trip to Kyoto changed both her skin and career path.


The Tatcha Water Cream is formulated with ingredients like Japanese Wild Rose, Japanese Leopard Lily, Hadasei-3™ complex and Tatcha’s signature anti-aging trio of green tea, rice and algae with a touch of 23-karat gold.

Here’s a more detailed description of the benefits of the ingredients found in Tatcha The Water Cream:

Japanese Wild Rose - This plant and key ingredient of Tatcha’s The Water Cream is a prolific botanical that produces much fruit or foliage such as rose hips. Its rose hips are abundant in Vitamins A, C and E and are also rich in flavonoids and tannins. Its fruits help in reducing pore appearance and improve skin tone and texture by supporting the skin’s natural barrier.

Japanese Leopard Lily- The leopard lily is one of perennial flowering plants of China, Japan and India in Central Asia. They grow from rhizomes and have been used in traditional medicines to treat conditions such as asthma, melasma and swelling and any other health issues. One of the benefits of this key ingredient from Tatcha’s Water Cream is that it helps control excess oil and clarifies skin by encouraging natural skin turnover.

Hadasei-3 complex- The last main or key ingredient of Tatcha’s The Water Cream consists of Okinawa Red Algae Extract, Green Tea Extract and Japanese Rice Bran. One of its components, the Okinawa Red Algae, provides a vital source of Beterhelin – a natural polysaccharide which is proven to enhance the skin’s barrier function for long lasting moisture retention and skin texture improvement.

Other ingredients of this water cream include:

  • Dimethicone
  • Glycerin
  • Sodium hyaluronate

The Tatcha Water Cream is said to visibly tighten pores and smooth out skin texture (Japanese Wild Rose), control excess oil and purify skin for natural turn over (Japanese leopard lily) and restore skin’s radiance (Hadasei-3 complex).


Most people would claim that the Tatcha Water Cream is worth the price as they think it’s a perfect lightweight moisturizer for the warm weather.

According to Dr. Marisa Garshick, MD, FAAD at the Manhattan Dermatology and Cosmetic Surgery Centers,

"the Tatcha Water Cream is a good option for those with acne issues as it contains ingredients that help reduce oil production."

This luxurious skin care product from Tatcha provides nutrient-rich, balanced hydration. It is a unique water burst cream which breaks upon application to deeply deliver treatment benefits, hydrating your skin without leaving it sticky or greasy. 


The Tatcha Water Cream is particularly great for those with oily skin as the formula is completely oil-free and doesn’t leave a greasy feeling.

The Tatcha Water Cream is recommended for oily, normal to oily, skin types and they say its good for reducing large pores and anti-aging. It is formulated without harmful chemicals such as parabens, sulfates and phthalates and has a shelf life of 6 months upon opening this product.


There are also cons that we have to consider when using this moisturizer and that’s the fact that Tatcha Water Cream also contains some acne flaring ingredients like dimethicone.  Dimethicone is a type of silicone and in most cases it is fine, but the protective layer that it helps create could also trap oils onto the skin and lead to more breakouts if you are oily and acne prone. Dr. Garshick also noted that those with sensitive skin should be cautious(1) when using this product since the various botanical ingredients and natural fragrances might cause contact dermatitis, which can appear in the form of redness, dryness or itching. 


You can use this water cream daily, both morning and nighttime. Scoop a pearl-sized amount of this water cream using a gold spoon then massage onto the face, neck and lower neckline in upward strokes.

Now let's compare the Banish Vitamin C Creme next.


What's the Banish Vitamin C Creme? The vitamin C cream from Banish, on the other hand, offers a unique moisturizer formula for oily and acne prone skin types. The Vitamin C creme from Banish is a lightweight vitamin c cream that wears well under makeup or sunscreen.

This creme can also be considered as a vitamin c moisturizer since it also helps hydrate the skin, leaving your skin feeling fresh, youthful, clear and glowing. This cream absorbs quickly into the skin for a non-greasy feeling for people with oily or combination types of skin and is formulated with 20% concentration of Vitamin C.

The Banish Vitamin C Creme can be used even though you don’t have any acne scars and it benefits all skin types.


One of the benefits of the Banish Vitamin C Creme is that it boosts elasticity to leave your skin firmer, brighter and smoother. It is made with natural ingredients to promote healthy skin. Daily use of this vitamin C cream helps in firming and brightening your skin as well as preventing any skin damage due to antioxidant properties and it helps with reducing the appearance of fine lines. 

The Banish Vitamin C Creme helps to reduce  the appearance of dark marks, firms the skin, improves evenness of skin tone and hydrating your skin without leaving a filmy, heavy or greasy residue. 


The ingredients found in the Banish Vitamin C Creme are:

  • Aloe Barbadensis/Organic Leaf Juice
  • Glycerin
  • Rosa Canina/Rosehip Fruit Oil
  • Emulsifying Wax NF
  • Ascorbyl Palmitate

1) Aloe Barbadensis/Organic Leaf Juice - Commonly known as Aloe Vera, its leaf juice is extracted from the leaves of the Aloe plant itself. This plant has been used for medicinal purposes for several thousands of years in different cultures. The Aloe Vera or Aloe Barbadensis leaf juice helps soothe the skin and serves as an anti-inflammatory. It can also heal burns and wounds, reduce scars and protect skin from UV damage.

2) Glycerin - This ingredient is like a sponge that pulls in water to the outer skin layer, attracting water from the deeper skin layers and slows its evaporation from your skin to help foil chronic winter dryness . Glycerin acts as a powerhouse moisturizer mixed with other emollients. It can be an incredibly moisturizer when used in a cleanser, removing any dirt and oil from your face.

3) Rosa Canina/Rosehip Fruit Oil - This ingredient in the vitamin C creme comes from the seed of the rosehip fruit and is rich in essential fatty acids. The Rosehip Oil contains high omega fatty acid content (51% linoleic acid, 19% linolenic acid and 20% oleic acid) and contains skin regenerative properties. One common misconception about rosehip oil is that it contains Vitamin C as the fruit itself does – The Vitamin C is not contained in oil as it is a water-soluble vitamin. Its antioxidant and regenerative properties come from oil soluble tocopherols (Vitamin E) and carotenoids (Vitamin A).

4) Emulsifying Wax NF – The emulsifying wax (2) acts as a binding agent for water and oil for them to mix and blend together in making toners, lotions and facial moisturizers. Emulsifying Wax NF is a complete vegetable-derived emulsifying wax that is used to create oil-in-water emulsions. It promotes easy and quick absorption of other ingredients by the skin.

5) Ascorbyl Palmitate - This type of Vitamin C is an oil soluble form which is facilitated by bonding it with palmitic acid. Ascorbyl Palmitate or Vitamin C Ester is one of the most stable forms of Vitamin C to use in formulation and is readily absorbed by the skin, combating free radicals leading to unhealthy aging skin. This more stable form of vitamin c is also not as irritating to skin compared to other forms of vitamin c.

The benefits we can get from the Banish Vitamin C Creme, as mentioned above, is that it boosts elasticity to leave your skin firmer, brighter and smoother. Moreover, it helps in firming and brightening your skin as well as preventing any skin damage with its antioxidant properties and reduces any appearance of fine lines.


To use the Banish Vitamin C Creme, apply a small pea sized and dab daily on clean skin and massage it in. It may take a few seconds for the cream to fully absorb. If you need further hydration, you can apply your favorite oils or additional moisturizer on top. Best to apply a sunscreen after to protect the Vitamin C from oxidizing if applied during the day.


This vitamin c cream for the face has a moderately thick texture that is easy to spread out over the skin and transforms into a much thinner consistency once it is spread onto skin. It has a really nice almost neutral scent, almost like a cold cream which is very nostalgic! This face cream for acne scars is really easy to apply and it works quite well as a day or night cream. Not to mention, it is fragrance free so any slight scent is due to the natural ingredients in the vitamin c cream.

The Banish Vitamin C Creme is good to use especially for those who have oily & combination skin types as well as dry or sensitive skin.  


Banish skincare offers a unique moisturizer formula for oily, acne-prone skin in this Vitamin C Creme, which is:

  • light
  • non-greasy
  • hydrating
  • healing and repairing

The Banish Vitamin C Creme has a light texture and is made with natural and fresh ingredients.

If you’re looking for a moisturizer that will fight your acne without clogging your pores and creating more issues, this gentle formula is a safe bet.


Many people use topical creams, medications, foods, and supplements to help relieve acne. In fact, vitamin C is frequently added to many skin care products that purport to treat it.

Vitamin C is a potent antioxidant which helps neutralize free radicals. Your skin’s epidermis — the top layer of skin that’s visible to the human eye — contains high levels of vitamin C (3). This nutrient plays a key role in protecting, healing, and producing new skin.

Keep in mind that while a high intake of foods rich in vitamin C may help other aspects of skin health, no research ties dietary vitamin C to reduced acne levels. Nonetheless, limited research suggests that the topical application of vitamin C may be helpful.


Vitamin C can be good for the face because it's highly acidic. When vitamin C is used topically "the skin is triggered to heal itself by accelerating the production of collagen and elastin," explains New York City-based dermatologist Howard Sobel.

However there are some downsides to Vitamin C, higher concentrations of vitamin c can be irritating.

“However, not all vitamin C products are created equal—and they can be irritating and finicky to use in some cases.”– Angela Lamb, MD Director of Westside Mount Sinai Dermatology Faculty Practice.

Fortunately, the form of Vitamin C used in the Banish Vitamin C Creme is stabilized and suitable for sensitive skin. 

We hope that this information helps you compare the differences between the Tatcha Water Cream and the Banish Vitamin C Creme.  Although both products are similar in terms of the category of being a moisturizer, there are quite a few key differences in the main ingredients that both products use and whether or not you have acne prone skin.   




1 Tatcha's Lightweight Water Cream Moisturizer Helped Me Get My Oil Production Under Control And Clear Up The Acne I'd Developed From Using A Too Heavy Face Cream" by Stephanie Lin from Insider; https://www.insider.com/tatcha-water-cream-review

2 “What Are The Benefits Of Emulsifying Wax?” from Raw Chemistry; https://rawchemistry.com/blogs/news/what-are-the-benefits-of-emulsifying-wax

3 "Everything You Need To Know About Vitamin C, The Holy Grail Of Skin Care Ingredients" by Rebecca Dancer from Allure; https://www.allure.com/story/vitamin-c-benefits-for-skin

Reading next

top acne myths

Leave a comment

All comments are moderated before being published.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.